PharmaPatents Timely Insight on Emerging Legal Developments

Tag Archives: 291

Federal Circuit Says Regulatory Patent Term Extension Prolongs Life of Entire Patent

Posted in Federal Circuit Decisions; Patent Term Extension

wrote previously about the patentability issues raised in Genetics Institute, LLC v. Novartis Vaccines & Diagnostics, Inc., and Novartis’ ability to rely on unexpected results discovered after the filing date to support non-obviousness.  Here, I look at another interesting issue in the case, related to the scope of a patent term extension under 35 USC § 156 and district court jurisdiction under 35 USC § 291.

The Technology At Issue

The technology at issue relates to truncated forms of Factor VIII, an essential blood-clotting protein. As explained in the Federal Circuit opinion, the proper functioning of Factor VIII depends on its ability to bind another protein, von Willedbrand factor (“vWF”), although Factor VIII can exhibit a procoagulant effect without complexing to vWF. Truncated forms of Factor VIII are based on the discovery that certain portions of the protein are not required for its procoagulant activity, and that region a3 is critical to vWF binding.

Continue reading this entry

Federal Circuit Won’t Let Creative Compounds Muscle Its Way Into Priority Of Invention

Posted in 102; Federal Circuit Decisions

In Creative Compounds, LLC v. Starmark Laboratories, the Federal Circuit clarified that the “clear and convincing” burden of proof applies to an allegation of prior invention unless an action is brought under 35 USC § 291 or the parties identify and agree on common claimed subject matter and seek an adjudication of priority.  While Patent Reform may do away with the specific provisions at issue in this case, at least some of the principles may carry over to the proposed “derivation” proceedings.

Continue reading this entry